Established neighborhood community in Siesta Key, Sarasota. Homes here trade as resales through the MLS, so pricing is set by recent Bay Island Shores sales rather than a builder price sheet.
Siesta Key is the barrier island home to one of the country's most celebrated beaches, with Siesta Village at the north end and quieter canal and bayfront neighborhoods to the south.
Sarasota spans downtown bayfront residences, the Palmer Ranch neighborhoods near Siesta Key, and newer master plans east of I-75. It combines arts and culture, strong healthcare, and some of the best-known beaches in the country.
OM
Your Sarasota buyer's agent: Oday Marogi
I spent 25 years in mortgage lending before I became a REALTOR®. That matters on a resale purchase, where financing terms and appraisal gaps decide who wins the house.
$29.2M2025 sales volume
31homes closed in 2025
EliteCircle of Excellence
#1Top Individual Agent Sales Volume, KW On The Water Sarasota
2025 Rookie of the Year, Keller Williams On The Water Sarasota.
I set up a live MLS alert for Bay Island Shores so you see new listings, price drops and back-on-market homes first.
We tour the homes that fit, and I pull recent Bay Island Shores sales so you know what each one is really worth.
I negotiate price, inspection repairs and credits, then manage the file through closing.
Bay Island Shores questions
Can I buy new construction in Bay Island Shores?
Bay Island Shores is an established community, so homes are sold as resales through the MLS rather than by a builder. I can set up an instant alert so you see every new Bay Island Shores listing the day it hits the market.
Is Bay Island Shores a 55+ community?
No. Bay Island Shores is open to buyers of all ages.
Does Bay Island Shores have a CDD fee?
Many new communities in Sarasota County carry a CDD that appears on the property tax bill. I'll confirm whether Bay Island Shores has one and the exact amount before you commit.
Where is Bay Island Shores located?
Bay Island Shores is in Sarasota, Sarasota County. It is part of Siesta Key.